Sunday, November 15, 2026

Michael Rosen: There is no Jewish Pope. So Who Speaks for all Jews?

            In Greek mythology, Erysichthon, also sometimes called Aethon, ended up eating himself


Michael Rosen*

London UK

Website Michael Rosen.co.UK 

also: http://www.booktrusted.co.uk/childrenslaureate

on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/michael.rosen.5496


The 'he' in this comment is me: 'he's a self loathing JINO Kapo so pet Jews like him don't count.' It was posted in a thread about a report in the Bookseller magazine that Jews and Israelis are allegedly being excluded or cancelled from the publishing industry.

 

Someone said (very kindly) that I wasn't cancelled and - she added - rightly so.

 

Then someone added this comment above.

 

Let's unpack it, shall we?

 

A 'JINO' is an acronym for 'Jewish in name only'. A 'kapo' is a term lifted from Holocaust times, when some Jews were accused of being collaborative police or camp guards assisting the SS and soldiers to kill Jews. 

 

The phrases 'self-loathing Jew' and 'pet Jew' come from a long history of accusing a Jew of not being faithful to whichever bit of Judaism or Zionism (or both) that the accuser believes in. The 'pet Jew' accusation is that I am indulged in as an inferior, fawning, loyal, obsequious creature, partly because I look up to non-Jews as superior to me. 

 

The 'don't count' bit is a kind of quote from David Baddiel's ironic title 'Jews Don't Count' booklet, which alleged that Jews were excluded from the discourse around anti-racism. 

 

Here the person posting this comment seems to be using the phrase unironically, meaning quite literally that I don't count ie don't matter, or that I am irrelevant to the argument as to whether Jews and Israelis are or are not excluded from the publishing industry. 

 

The argument then is that I'm a particular kind of person who has managed to get published on account of the fact that a) I hate myself, b) I'm not really Jewish c) I collaborate with antisemites and/or Nazis d) I am a toady to non-Jews, abasing myself, in order to win affection and reward and e) on account of these 'facts', I am irrelevant to the discussion. 

 

I find myself wondering what kind of worldview might lead someone to think such things and then to post them in a public forum. Some of it is so exaggerated as to be puzzling. Self-loathing? Really? Narcissistic? Perhaps! Loathing my Jewishness? Really? Is that why I write about it, perform it in my performances, research it, study it, struggle each day to read some Yiddish in the Hebrew alphabet ('alef-beys')? 

 

Then the JINO insult. I guess this comes from people who are observant and religious who feel annoyed that non-observant and non-religious Jews call themselves Jews. 

 

All religions struggle with orthodoxies and go in for a mix of expulsions, line-drawing, distinction-making, inter-sect rivalries and the like. 

 

At various times in my life, I've read about the Reformation, Puritanism, religious wars, the English Civil War and the like. The closer you get to the pamphlets and sermons of the time, the more you get to see the fury and rage of sects cursing each other for not being 'right' or not being 'pure'. Famously, there was the dispute over 'transubstantiation' and 'consubstantiation'. 

 

The irony in all this is that some of the most famous founders of Zionism and the state of Israel were non-observant, non-religious Jews and this continues to this day. If people are interested, I can provide a list! And, rather obviously, there is no overarching authority on such matters.

 

There is no Jewish Pope, no Jewish Archbishop or Patriarch who rules over all Jews. In fact, further irony, some Jews (eg some Haredi Jews) regard non-Haredi Jews as not being real Jews! In other words, the accusers are sometimes themselves accused! 


*Michael Rosen is an author of children’s books and a professor at Goldsmith’s University of London

No comments: