Monday, November 28, 2022

Vatican Inc. Introduces New Guidelines For Investors. Is There Cause For Concern?


Richard Mellor

Afscme Local 444, retired
GED/HEO

I see Vatican Inc. has instructed Catholic institutions throughout the world to invest their capital in ways that are in accordance with Catholic teachings, or “faith-consistent investing”. I am not sure if these guidelines, issued as “MENSURAM BONAM” Faith-Based Measures for Catholic Investors:  A Starting Point and Call to Action, apply to individual Catholic investors, hedge fund managers, speculators and other social parasites. One can’t help wonder if the ten Vatican employees, including a cardinal, on trial for money laundering, fraud and embezzlement has contributed to this revolutionary announcement. The trial is a Vatican trial so we know it will be fair.


The new guidelines call on Catholic institutions to avoid companies that produce violent video games (the US military is a big player, in the violent video game market) drugs that “induce” abortion (not sure about condom manufacturers) or the fossil fuel industry and I assume planned Parenthood is out. I didn't read the entire Vatican document but in the reports I read in the media, there was no mention of not investing in WalMart, Target, Apple or any company that uses workers in countries that crush unions, or bar them altogether, many of them brutal undemocratic regimes. In fact, the Vatican sees no problem with expoiting workers just doing it in a way that will not offend god.


The US Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) like others throughout the world, have their own guidelines apparently and the Vatican hopes they will tow the Vatican line to put it bluntly. One issue particular to the US and the USCCB is those companies that produce drugs used in state or federal executions by lethal injection. One problem from the start is that according to the reports I have read, many US dioceses have significant investments in the oil and other fossil fuel industries but the most recent USCCB guidelines adopted in 2021 call for investing, “in companies whose business models are consistent with the emission reduction goals of the Paris Agreement” so we should all be safe with that revolutionary decision.


Other industries the Vatican suggests are not appropriate investment opportunities, is the pornography industry (a difficult habit to break as about anyone with a computer enjoys the programming at
some point or another) and Genetically Modified seeds because the lawyers for haven’t won that battle yet. A little more money will have to change hands first. The Vatican’s hesitation is that, “environmental and health risks not yet precisely defined”.


Arms Manufacturers

A big problem will be the arms industry that is included in the Vatican blacklist. The profits are very lucrative for this branch of capital investment. What with all the conflict throughout the world and in particular the proxy war with Russia the US is waging in Ukraine. Western arms manufacturers are running short of weapons from bullets to missiles due to the heroic defense of Ukraine, national sovereignty and democracy; using their own workers on the battlefield is not in the plans . Arms manufacturers in Europe are increasing capacity to meet the demand as there has been too much peace in Europe for too long. It’s even increased mergers as producers of weapons of mass destruction try to keep up.

European arms manufacturers have gained significantly and shares of German and Swedish arms manufacturers “….have soared on hopes of big orders” the
Wall Street Journal reports. It’s uplifting to hear that manufacturers are doing their best to bring peace to the world: “You have to make an entrepreneurial decision……the customers will give contracts to the companies who have the capacity.”, says the CEO of Rheinmetall the largest of Germany’s arms manufacturers which is looking to gobble up a rival in order to compete with the demand.

The US has committed $17 billion to Ukraine for weapons and another $3.5 billion to beef up US supplies as well as its allies as the wonderful market for weapons has blossomed to the point that domestic supplies are running low. The free market is a wonderful thing.

The arms business is on fire. The US has ordered stinger missiles from Raytheon Corp. that were so important in liberating Iraq and Afghanistan and that the taxpayer hasn’t purchased since 2008. “Lockheed Martin Corp. is doubling output of the Javelin antitank missiles it coproduces with Raytheon, and it is boosting output of Himars rocket launchers and GMLRS missiles by 60%.”, according to reports in the media. The generosity of the US taxpayer in this struggle for world peace is admirable.

Shares in US and European arms producers are up and running in 2022:

BAE Systems (UK) 40%
Saab ( Sweden)30%
Lockheed Martin US 36%
General Dynamics (US) 22%
Raytheon (US) 12%
Rheinmetall (Germany) 115%

Even South Korea is selling artillery shells to Ukraine (These would be made in the US I suppose.) under what the media describes as a “confidential” deal with the US. Surely it’s not that confidential as I know about it.

In the midst of this booming peace industry, the Vatican’s veiled threat that Catholics participating in these ventures through capital investment could end up in hell, it’s quite likely there is some panic brewing among those involved.

These honorable market players, probably many of them the same investors in the oil and fossil fuel industries need not fret though. The Cardinal---those are the guys with the rather large colorful hats but not as large and colorful as the Pope’s--- that oversaw the development of the guidelines, stresses that the guidelines are only advisory and the Vatican is not demanding Catholics divest from companies on the list.

Note: much of the information is this commentary is from the Wall Street Journal and New York Times

No comments: