Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Ken Klippenstein: Chuck Schumer’s Psychological Operation

Chuck Schumer’s Psychological Operation

Don’t fall for Washington’s mind games about Chris Van Hollen

Ken Klippenstein 11-16-26

Help me stay on the Schumer vs. Van Hollen story by becoming a paid subscriber (or via my GoFundMe here)

In the war between Senators Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen for who will be the next Majority Leader, a psychological operation is being carried out against all of us.

When Van Hollen announced his challenge, Schumer’s response was petulant. He didn’t explain why he was the better choice. He didn’t say what he’d do differently, even though different is exactly what voters across the country just voted for.

Instead, Schumer fell back on process. He has the votes, he insisted, so a contested election and a public debate are unnecessary. It’s like he doesn’t think he should have to apply for the job at all.

The Washington media, as uninterested in the world outside Washington as Schumer is, covered it as a backroom, Washington-centric story. Headlines blared Schumer’s claim that he already has the votes, framing the entire issue as a fait accompli requiring no further discussion. No comment about the old guard maintaining the levers of power, no explanation of how much it’s in Schumer’s interest to close off debate, no acknowledgment that it is a Washington playbook trying to shape people’s perception of what’s possible.

“I have the votes” 

“I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader,” Schumer said last week in response to Van Hollen’s challenge.

On Saturday, The Hill reported that “Schumer’s allies” expect he’ll win an “overwhelming majority” of votes to become leader.

“We’re done here,” declared Adam Jentleson, former chief of staff to Sen. John Fetterman (who has endorsed Schumer), in a social media post linking to The Hill’s story. “Time to move on and focus on delivering for Americans who put their faith in Democrats to deliver real, tangible improvements in their lives.”

Apparently “delivering for Americans” doesn’t include listening to them. A majority of Americans, including Democrats, have consistently disapproved of Schumer — even after the midterm blowout. 

Even on the narrow question of who has the votes, it’s not clear at all that that’s Schumer. The problem with Schumer’s account is that, as of today, only 16 of the Democrats’ 55 senators have publicly endorsed him. Van Hollen, meanwhile, says Schumer is lying and that several senators Schumer claims as supporters have actually endorsed Van Hollen. Schumer, he says, is trying to manufacture a sense of inevitability to scare people out of supporting anyone else. (Sound like the Biden White House stiff-arming any challenger to the president?)

“The Schumer team’s put out a lot of misinformation,” Van Hollen told ABC’s This Week on Sunday. “They’re essentially trying to instill fear in people who may say that they’re going to support me as a new leader.”

Schumer is reaching for another Washington trick, too. He is trying to move the vote up to two weeks from now, to head off the leadership debate.

“Let’s not rush into a coronation,” Van Hollen says. 

The Schumer Psy-Op

Manufactured inevitability is one of the oldest psychological tricks in the Washington playbook. The beauty of it is that instead of having to win an argument, they just declare it already over. And it isn’t aimed only at senators. It’s aimed at the rest of us, too: the voters, activists, anyone whose pressure might actually force changes, if only they thought it was possible.

Social scientists have a name for what happens next: “pluralistic ignorance.” In a 2022 study in Nature Communications, researchers found that 66 to 80 percent of Americans support major climate policies. But Americans guessed that only 37 to 43 percent of their fellow citizens did. Supporters outnumbered opponents roughly two to one, yet the public believed nearly the opposite.

Perception often becomes reality. People who think they’re in the minority tend to drift toward what they believe everyone else thinks, and they stop pushing. “They fall into a trap of: I support this but I think other people don’t,” the study’s lead author, Gregg Sparkman, said.

In Washington, declaring a race “over” before a single ballot is cast is a tool of political control. It serves two audiences at once. Inside the Capitol, leaked whip counts and “overwhelming majority” headlines signal to undecided senators and incoming freshmen that opposing the incumbent is futile and even career-limiting. Outside the Capitol, the message to voters is even simpler: there is nothing to see here, no debate worth having, and no reason for you to call your senator.

There’s another benefit of the Schumer psy-op. By treating Schumer’s re-election as a foregone conclusion, party insiders can avoid answering the substantive questions Van Hollen’s challenge forces onto the table — whether, for example, Democrats should reject AIPAC money, whether they will block funding for the war in Iran, and whether the new majority will confront corporate power or slip back into the same cautious habits that left Schumer with his abysmal approval rating in the first place.

You’re not alone

Another demonstration comes from an unlikely place: Saudi Arabia.

In a 2020 study in the American Economic Review, economists found that the vast majority of young married Saudi men privately supported women working outside the home. But they badly underestimated how many other men agreed, even their own neighbors.

So the researchers told a random group of the men the real numbers. Those men became more willing to help their wives look for jobs. Four months later, their wives were more likely to have applied and interviewed for work outside the home.

Nobody’s mind was changed. The men just learned they weren’t alone.

The most damning American example is segregation.

In a 1975 study in Public Opinion Quarterly, sociologist Hubert O’Gorman went back to national survey data from 1968. He found that most white Americans grossly exaggerated how many other whites still supported segregation. Their private views had moved on. They assumed their neighbors’ hadn’t. So they went along with a system most of them no longer believed in.

Schumer is exploiting the same psychological blind spot. You don’t have to change anyone’s mind. You only have to convince people that they’re alone.

The news media failed to predict the magnitude of public discontent with the generation in power. It doesn’t seem interested in discovering the real America now, or what people want. It prefers the binary of Democrat vs. Republican, without ever asking: Democrat what?

Instead it covers the “race” for the majority and, of course, 2028.

Go back to sleep, America. We’ll call you again in two years when we need your vote — er, input.

Help me stay on the Schumer vs. Van Hollen story by becoming a paid subscriber (or via my GoFundMe 

Monday, November 16, 2026

The Democrats Midterms Victory is Not a Social Movement


Richard Mellor

Afscme Local 444, retired

11-16-26

Some thoughts on what the Democratic Party's electoral victory is and what it night mean in the future if this party doesn't deliver. It is likely some of the extreme measures from the Trump Administration will be rolled back particularly on the environment and health side; the party has to produce something. If they do not, those Republicans that feel betrayed by Trump and voted Democratic, would just as easily swing back the other way. The electoral arena is the only game in town at this point. And some 100 million Americans have abandoned it altogether.  The Democratic Party’s obsession with identity politics and cultural issues contributed significantly to the rise and election of Trump in the first place. 

 

However, this is not a movement anything close to the uprisings we are seeing around the world from France to Ecuador, Spain, Greece, Albania and so on. Many long-time Republicans voted Democratic due to the madness and betrayal of the Trump Administration; it was clearly an anti-Trump vote. 

 

There are splits among the right wing and regular MAGA Trump supporters. Tucker Carlson has talked of forming a new party with the America Firsters as they feel betrayed. If you have any doubts about Carlson's views on secularism, Christian Nationalism and domestic policies, watch his speech at Charlie Kirk's memorial. 

 

Also, as I mention in the video, the leaders of organized labor in the US are, as always, the Dogs that Never Bark. Their inactivity in the face of the most right wing Administration in the modern era is staggering. Their support of the War Party, the Democrats, endured all through Biden, Blinken and Harris' backing of the Israeli gen*cide in Gaza and, as far as I can gather they've said nothing of substance on the unprovoked and illegal war on Iran. I should add that in the video I said 7% of US workers are organized but that’ just the private sector. The public sector has a higher unionization rate, around 30-35% (pre-Trump assault) so around 12 to 14 percent are in unions in the US. But they are in key industries.

 

It seems that Bernie Sanders has some competition for his position as the number one recruiter for the Democratic Party as Zohran Mamdani met last week with some trade union leaders in order to develop a strategy to elect more "progressive's" in the next period. He reiterated his admiration for Alexandria Ocasio Cortez stressing she would be great in any position. But it is highly unlikely that AOC as she is often called, will risk her rise to stardom and a chance at a presidential run in 2028 by supporting left candidates. Belonging to DSA doesn’t mean much here in the US. 

 

He spoke with the Painters Union president even suggesting he run for political office. Might I suggest given the thousands on the ground and in the community that supported Mamdani, that he makes use of this working class base and they spend some time with rank and file trade unionists whenever the mood among organized labor is sought; and also to build solid links with them in general. this will give him a more accurate sense of what the folks in organised labor that pay the dues and walk the picket lines are thinking. 

 

He also met with Flight attendants president Sara Nelson who has floated the idea of a General Strike on occasion but there seems to be no such discussion within the AFL-CIO executive on this issue and certainly no sign of any effort to organise one. 

 

Anyway, as with most Tik Tok video's they have to be short and social media, while important can't replace mass meetings and on the ground contact and this was a quick few comments on that forum, which ironically, seems much more restricted and censored than it did when the Chinese owned it. So my comments are not a dissertation, just some views from a worker that reads as Brecht's poem was. titled.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Michael Rosen: There is no Jewish Pope. So Who Speaks for all Jews?

            In Greek mythology, Erysichthon, also sometimes called Aethon, ended up eating himself


Michael Rosen*

London UK

Website Michael Rosen.co.UK 

also: http://www.booktrusted.co.uk/childrenslaureate

on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/michael.rosen.5496


The 'he' in this comment is me: 'he's a self loathing JINO Kapo so pet Jews like him don't count.' It was posted in a thread about a report in the Bookseller magazine that Jews and Israelis are allegedly being excluded or cancelled from the publishing industry.

 

Someone said (very kindly) that I wasn't cancelled and - she added - rightly so.

 

Then someone added this comment above.

 

Let's unpack it, shall we?

 

A 'JINO' is an acronym for 'Jewish in name only'. A 'kapo' is a term lifted from Holocaust times, when some Jews were accused of being collaborative police or camp guards assisting the SS and soldiers to kill Jews. 

 

The phrases 'self-loathing Jew' and 'pet Jew' come from a long history of accusing a Jew of not being faithful to whichever bit of Judaism or Zionism (or both) that the accuser believes in. The 'pet Jew' accusation is that I am indulged in as an inferior, fawning, loyal, obsequious creature, partly because I look up to non-Jews as superior to me. 

 

The 'don't count' bit is a kind of quote from David Baddiel's ironic title 'Jews Don't Count' booklet, which alleged that Jews were excluded from the discourse around anti-racism. 

 

Here the person posting this comment seems to be using the phrase unironically, meaning quite literally that I don't count ie don't matter, or that I am irrelevant to the argument as to whether Jews and Israelis are or are not excluded from the publishing industry. 

 

The argument then is that I'm a particular kind of person who has managed to get published on account of the fact that a) I hate myself, b) I'm not really Jewish c) I collaborate with antisemites and/or Nazis d) I am a toady to non-Jews, abasing myself, in order to win affection and reward and e) on account of these 'facts', I am irrelevant to the discussion. 

 

I find myself wondering what kind of worldview might lead someone to think such things and then to post them in a public forum. Some of it is so exaggerated as to be puzzling. Self-loathing? Really? Narcissistic? Perhaps! Loathing my Jewishness? Really? Is that why I write about it, perform it in my performances, research it, study it, struggle each day to read some Yiddish in the Hebrew alphabet ('alef-beys')? 

 

Then the JINO insult. I guess this comes from people who are observant and religious who feel annoyed that non-observant and non-religious Jews call themselves Jews. 

 

All religions struggle with orthodoxies and go in for a mix of expulsions, line-drawing, distinction-making, inter-sect rivalries and the like. 

 

At various times in my life, I've read about the Reformation, Puritanism, religious wars, the English Civil War and the like. The closer you get to the pamphlets and sermons of the time, the more you get to see the fury and rage of sects cursing each other for not being 'right' or not being 'pure'. Famously, there was the dispute over 'transubstantiation' and 'consubstantiation'. 

 

The irony in all this is that some of the most famous founders of Zionism and the state of Israel were non-observant, non-religious Jews and this continues to this day. If people are interested, I can provide a list! And, rather obviously, there is no overarching authority on such matters.

 

There is no Jewish Pope, no Jewish Archbishop or Patriarch who rules over all Jews. In fact, further irony, some Jews (eg some Haredi Jews) regard non-Haredi Jews as not being real Jews! In other words, the accusers are sometimes themselves accused! 


*Michael Rosen is an author of children’s books and a professor at Goldsmith’s University of London

Michael Roberts: Anti-Fascist Economics

by Michael Roberts

Isabella Weber is an associate professor of economics at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and an associate in research at the Fairbank Center, Harvard University. She is author of the prize-winning How China Escaped Shock Therapy – see my review of this book here. She has advised policy-makers in the US, Germany, Europe and Latin America. And she has been recognized by TIME Magazine on their 100 Next list.

Now she has a new book out, Anti-Fascist Economics: in defense of affordability, dignity and democracy, which is taking the economic and financial media by storm.  Weber is being interviewed on her book by myriads of leftist media sources and even has had an interview in the London Financial Times. Leftist journals like Jacobin have praised the book. At the same time, her views have been strongly attacked and dismissed by many mainstream economists.

Given that Weber grew up in Nuremberg, the German city where Adolf Hitler staged his vast Nazi rallies, the title of her new book can be no surprise.  Weber is deeply worried that fascist forces are gaining strength again in Europe: with the Alternativ fur Deutschland (AfD) in Germany; Rally Nationale in France; Vox in Spain, Chega in Portugal and Brothers of Italy – and similar parties in many other European states. 

The main theme of the book is to come up with economic policies that can win working people away from fascist ideas and revive democratic politics. For her, that means solving the cost of living crisis and delivering basic services in education, health and housing that are badly missing. If living costs are curbed and basic services delivered, Weber hopes that fascist forces will be weakened and defeated.  I think she is right on that.

But the increase in support for the anti-democratic right is result of decades of fiscal austerity that has cut public services to ribbons and increasing economic insecurity for the majority. Weber maintains that the core of the problem is ‘market fundamentalism’ —the notion that the market self-regulates and is best left to operate on its own. This is really “profit fundamentalism,” a zero-sum, winner-takes-all pursuit that benefits the ultrawealthy at the expense of the rest. 

OK. So what’s the answer?  What are the policies needed to end the rising cost of living, precarious jobs and crushed public services in economies dominated by big finance, big business and big tech led by super-rich oligarchs? For an answer, Weber looks to what she calls the various founders of ‘anti-fascist economics’: namely, Karl Polanyi, John Maynard Keynes, Michał Kalecki; Franklin Delano Roosevelt and John Kenneth Galbraith – but not,it seems, Karl Marx. Indeed, she criticises the German Social Democrats of the early 20th century for sticking to the ‘dogma’ of Marx’s labour theory of value rather developing ‘practical policies’ to meet economic crisis of the 1920s Germany that eventually brought Nazism to power.

Like so many leftist reformers before her, she argues that there is a viable ‘middle ground’ between two straw men: a totalitarian command economy (presumably Soviet ‘socialism’?) and the free market. So we need to return to the theories and policies of the ‘middle road’ as represented by the social democracy of the post-WW2 period of Keynesian macro management.

Weber writes that anti-fascist economics “removes the economic anxiety and sense of overwhelming crisis that fascists exploit, and it demonstrates—concretely, in people’s daily lives—that democratic governments can act in their interest.”  So what is in this antibiotic that can kill the fascist disease? Weber concentrates her ideas on policies to control inflation to restablish ‘affordability’. What is driving people towards fascism boils down to the unaffordability of living and ever rising living costs. Inflation in 1920s Germany did exactly that. 

What has been the cause of the inflationary spiral since the end of the pandemic slump?  She argues (in a series of papers and op-eds) that the cause was not ‘excessive demand’ caused by government spending or excessive wage demands but what she has caled ‘sellers’ inflation’. Her central argument is that when supply shocks occur, like the global supply chain collapse in the pandemic or say the energy crisis from the Iran war, they can drive up prices throughout an economy. Because oil is an input in countless other goods, many producers passed on the price shock by raising their sale prices.

This is undoubtedly a correct analysis of accelerating inflation post the pandemic. It was clearly due to a ‘supply shock’ and not excessive demand. Consequently, conventional monetary policy of hiking interest rates or tightening money supply will not curb inflation, but instead raise the cost of borrowing for households (mortgages) and businesses (loan rates) and so risk a slump. I argued similarly during the post-pandemic period.

But how do we curb inflation then? Weber’s answer is price controls.  Governments must not leave inflation to the vagaries of markets dominated by monopolies that can hike prices to preserve or increase profits. As Weber puts it: “Commodity markets are inherently volatile, and the human cost of leaving them entirely to private participants falls hardest on those least able to absorb it, while carrying the potential to destabilize whole economies and societies.” Indeed, but are price controls the answer?  Controlling energy prices for the domestic consumer would not solve price rises at the producer end, but simply drive private energy distributors into bankruptcy. That would force governments to subsidise them with funds or end controls or take over failing companies. 

During the post-pandemic energy surge in 2021 and 2022, the French government forced the state-owned Électricité de France (EDF) to cap household electricity price increases at 4% as part of a nationwide “tariff shield” (bouclier tarifaire). While this policy shielded French consumers from the severe cost-of-living shocks seen across the rest of Europe, it triggered massive financial losses for EDF and eventually led to the company’s full nationalization. In my view, the latter poses the best policy solution anyway: public ownership of the international energy and food companies that operate throughout the global supply chain would enable national governments to set prices rather than profit-seeking moguls.

But public ownership of ‘price gouging’ companies is not on the agenda of Weber’s anti-fascist economics. Instead, she offers an alternative that keeps energy, tech, finance in the hands of capital. She suggests that governments should build up ‘buffer stocks’ to smooth out supply shocks when they occur. The state could ‘regulate’ prices by creating substantial reserves of nonperishable goods — especially food and fossil fuels, by buying en masse when they are cheap and selling when prices rise. Price controls can therefore be entirely viable if they are implemented through supply management, rather than mere fiat. Naturally, mainstream economists reject buffer stocks as a method of price control, arguing that such policies will not cope with speculation or the risk of governments having to fork out monies to balance the cost of stocking if prices swing sharply.

In Anti-Fascist Economics, Weber cites various cases where price controls worked. There was the FDR-Galbraith administration during World War II, which sustained effective price controls.  And Weber argues that price controls in Communist China in its early years were very successful.  But these examples are misleading, in my view.  In WW2, US and UK governments were in full control of the major sectors of the economy in order to direct them to the war effort.  A war economy with the major companies and financial institutions working to a plan is nothing like the free-for all for the capitalist sector in profits and investment now. Total price control in an economy would require total control by the state of the oligopolies over investment and production. And total control would only be possible by taking the oligopolies into public ownership with a plan for investment and production. And that is why in China under Mao price controls were successful because ‘sellers inflation’ was not possible.

In post-pandemic capital economies, price controls will squeeze profits. Fine, you might say. But in a profit-driven capitalist economy that will only eventually lead to lower investment and productive growth (see France above). As one mainstream critique of buffers stocks concluded: “Even if public buffer stocks can promote price stability in the face of short-term supply shocks, they cannot sustainably address price changes that reflect longer-term structural changes.” In my view, those ‘long-term structural changes’ are when productivity growth slows because investment growth slows, leading to slowing supply relative to demand goods and services. It is this that is the underlying cause of rising inflation, not ‘price-gouging’ as such. In an economy dominated by profit-driven companies in energy and other key sectors producing basic necessities, prices will then rise. See the summary of my argument here.

Of course, Weber’s anti-fascist policies are not confined to controlling inflation.  She calls for “active government policies that would steer, manage or provision essentials.” On the provisioning side, she ‘defends’(?) a revitalization of public education, transportation, and health care under a framework of ‘universal basic services’. Weber reckons that we need a ‘strong state’ that actively counteracts inequalities with instruments such as industrial and social policy or tax reforms, strengthens social security and pro-actively manages crises (?) and processes of change.

Well yes, we need these things,but how can these be achieved in capitalist economies where public spending is being cut and and private investment growth is weak (excepting AI or defence)? Even if we had social democratic governments in Europe or the US prepared to tax the rich more and spend more on ‘universal basic services’, would this deliver fundamental change?

Weber quotes Polanyi where he says ‘The victory of fascism was made practically unavoidable by the liberals’ obstruction of any reform involving planning, regulation, or control.’  So Weber now appeals to the new Democrat majority in the US Congress: “Affordability just revived democracy (so not fascism after all). But to safeguard it, Democrats have to change the playbook, not just the slogans. The economy needs to be rebuilt from the essentials up — to restore public power, put a floor under livelihoods, and a ceiling on private wealth.“

As a review of Weber’s book in Jacobin pointed out, “readers of Anti-Fascist Economics who seek either an overarching theoretical critique of capitalism or a detailed policy agenda will not find everything they’re looking for. Weber is explicit that what she offers “are not blueprints but starting points.” My worry is that starting with just price controls, buffer stocks and taxing the rich is unlikely to get much beyond first base (to use a baseball analogy), while the finance, business and resources remain in the hands of a tiny minority of owners such as the Magnificent Seven. But no doubt Weber would see this criticism as ‘Marxist dogma’ that lacks ‘starting points’. The title of Weber’s book is instructive. It is Anti-Fascist Economics, not Anti-Capitalist Economics. Her aim is to restore (social) democracy and ‘dignity’ by managing capitalism, not replacing it.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Israel is a European Settler Colony. It was Never Anything But


Sir Ronald Storrs Governor of Jerusalem 1917-26
"Even though the land could not yet absorb sixteen million, nor even eight, enough could return, if not to form the Jewish State (which a few extremists publicly demanded), at least to prove that the enterprise was one that blessed him that gave [Britain] as well as him that took [Zionism] by forming for England a little loyal Jewish Ulster in a sea of potentially hostile Arabism."



John Clarke

Toronto 

Past Ontario Coalition Against Poverty (OCAP) organizer. Presently part of 230 Fightback

 

An important line must be drawn at this time. We have to be clear that the problem with Israel is not reducible to the brutal right-wing trajectory of its political leadership or the ugly views of the great bulk of its population. 


These factors are horrible and dangerous effects but they are not causes and they are not subject to any effective form of correction or modification. 

 

At this time, as Israel's crimes reach ever more deranged levels of atrocity, a trend is emerging that reluctantly admits something is very wrong but that seeks to present the problem as a set of faults that can be corrected. This subterfuge can't go unchallenged.

 

The establishment of a settler-colonial state on stolen Palestinian land, that served the interests of imperialism and regional domination, fundamentally defined the project in irreversible ways. Dispossession, ethnic cleansing, exclusion, occupation and genocide are defining traits of such an undertaking. 

 

The political ideology of Zionism, under which the colonial project has been conducted, though it has its variations and conflicting camps, has always served the purpose of creating and maintaining an ethnostate. As such, it is fundamentally and deeply racist in nature, even when its liberal wing and its international supporters try to square the circle.

 

This is why, as Israel's legitimacy implodes and ways are sought to salvage its reputation, it is imperative to advance a clear and principled perspective. We must declare, without equivocation, qualification or mealy mouthed apologies, the undeniable truth that Zionism is racism. 

Israel Silences and Tortures Palestinian Journalists.





Shaiel Ben Ephraim

11-13-26


An Unbelievable story on how Israel silences and tortures journalists, brought by the fantastic Nir Hasson of Haaretz. A Palestinian journalist was starved in Israeli prisons and spoke out about it. Israel arrested him again. When a judge found no case against him, a sealed envelope kept him locked up anyway.

 

1) Samer Khuweira, a journalist from Nablus, spent nine months in administrative detention. He was released in January with no charge, no trial and no evidence.

 

2) He lost 22 kilograms and came out with scabies. His nine-year-old son did not recognize him. Breakfast had been a spoonful of labneh measured against lines on a plastic cup.

 

3) About the sick prisoners in Megiddo, he said: “Have you ever seen walking skeletons? Their legs are covered in blood, their chests are covered in blood. We called them zombies.”

 

4) He asked a Shin Bet officer why he had been held. The officer said there was “no direct reason,” only that he and his friends were “Hamas.”

 

5) Three weeks after Haaretz published his account, soldiers arrested him at home for online “incitement.” The key posts dated from January 2025, and he had already been questioned about them.

 

6) The military judge called it an investigative failure and ordered him released on bail, citing press freedom as a “cornerstone of a democratic society.”

 

7) Khuweira shouted with joy on the phone line. Then the prosecutor handed the judge a sealed request for administrative detention. Three minutes later the judge ordered him held again.


Israel has detained 112 Palestinian journalists and media workers since the war began, according to CPJ. 38 were still held as of October 21.

 

The evidence couldn’t hold him. Secret evidence that he and his lawyers can’t see sent him back to the prisons he had just exposed. 


There is no freedom of the press in Israel. Especially not for Palestinians. 

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Veterans Day is Not about Thanking Veterans


One in three Iraq War Vets Believes it Wasn't Worth it. Source
It's About Ensuring We Have More of Them

Richard Mellor
Afscme Local 444, retired.

I just watched the start of Monday night Football in one of my local haunts and the San Francisco Forty Niners are playing the Seattle Seahawks. The national anthem is about to be sung by a man in uniform on a platform flanked by others in uniform. He is an Asian man by the looks of it, and in the US this means East and Southeast Asia it doesn’t mean an Indian, Bangladeshi or Pakistani like it would back home. He’s there to show the US military and US society as a whole is inclusive, and non racist.

Below him there are lines of people in military garb and a huge American flag is slowly unfurled on the ground. Perhaps there were jets flying around too as occurs on occasion to advertise US capitalism’s most advanced peace keeping equipment. I left before I could determine that.

The whole scene nauseates me and I let out a loud wow as the monster flag was slowly appearing on the pitch  A young couple sitting a few places over, hear me and the man quickly places his hand over his heart. Oh dear, I thought to myself, I am about to get in trouble. I say should we sit or are we all supposed to stand and the young woman says she too is unsure and feels unsure about it. She is Latina which is encouraging.  I then move on and say it reminds me a bit of Nazi, Germany, a bit too nationalistic for me I say.

I made some comment about the suicides in the military and the way they are treated when they return after finding themselves in the most horrible position of being shot at or having to shoot at another human being with the intention of ending their lives. I point out that those most aggressively campaigning for wars never fight in them and so on, that the rich don’t fight wars working people do.

The young man was clearly not offended by my remarks and I am not sure if he was unsure about my position and did not want to be seen to be enjoying a pint on veterans day without being sufficiently patriotic so he did the hand over heart thing. Either way, they were not gung ho on war and the military and had serious thoughts about the nature of it all. As I left I urged them to watch Sir No Sir as we also talked a little about the Vietnam War.

 But the reality is that the US is a very nationalistic and militaristic society. The draft was ended in 1973 so we have what they call an all-volunteer military force. As most workers don’t join the military for sadistic reasons, the conditions that draw them have to be created. Poverty, desperation or the lack of opportunity for employment and advancement is a big plus. Getting cheap loans, a free education are also used. As it is, less than 0.5 percent of the U.S. population is in the military. This has a crippling effect on a small number of families whose young sons and daughters are sent to defend US capitalism’s profits abroad.

The propaganda of patriotism and nationalism is very strong. We are told to “support the Troops” which means in reality that we must support US capitalism’s predatory wars. But the flag waving is all for when our young people are leaving these shores not so much when they return; this is common of all nations. Meanwhile, the opioid crisis has devastated young veterans and in 2018 325 active-duty members died by suicide.

Veterans of combat have always constituted a significant portion of the homeless, “Iraq and Afghanistan war veterans are facing elevated rates of suicide and mental illness, drug and alcohol dependence, car crashes, and homelessness.”, according to statistics, “At least 970,000 veterans have some degree of officially recognized disability as a result of the wars. Many more live with physical and emotional scars despite lack of disability status.”  Watson Institute: Costs of War.

For Veteran’s Day 2018, Caitlin Johnson, the Australian independent journalist wrote the following:

“The US will be celebrating Veterans Day tomorrow, and many a striped flag shall be waved. The social currency of esteem will be used to elevate those who have served in the US military, thereby ensuring future generations of recruits to be thrown into the gears of the globe-spanning war machine.

Veterans Day is not a holiday to honor the men and women who have dutifully protected their country. The youngest Americans who arguably defended their nation from a real threat to its shores are in their nineties, and soon there won’t be any of them left. Every single person who has served in the US military since the end of the second World War has protected nothing other than the agendas of global hegemony, resource control and war profiteering. They have not been fighting and dying for freedom and democracy, they have been fighting and dying for imperialism, Raytheon profit margins, and crude oil.”

"Last week I saw the hashtag #SaluteToService trending on Twitter. Apparently the NFL had a deal going where every time someone tweeted that hashtag they’d throw a few bucks at some veteran’s charity. Which sounds sweet, until you consider three things:

1. The NFL’s ten wealthiest team owners are worth a combined $61 billion.

2. The NFL has taken millions of dollars from the Pentagon for displays of patriotism on the field, including for the policy of bringing all players out for the national anthem every game starting in 2009 (which led to Colin Kaepernick’s demonstrations and the obscene backlash against him)."

This is an accurate account of what Veterans Day really is about in my view.

I want to remind, no urge the reader, to remember Pat Tillman. Tillman gave up fame and fortune in order to join the US military and defend his country from those that attacked it on September 11th 2001.  He was all over the media. Donald Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz and other warmongers took him and ran with him. He would be the poster boy for the US military. He would encourage young men to do the same and join up.

But Pat Tillman was a genuine leader and an honest person. Afghanistan and his experience in the military led him to draw different conclusions. He was not going to do the US warmonger’s bidding. He was not going to be the poster boy for military service. He has been airbrushed from history. He was killed by what we are expected to believe was friendly fire while serving in Afghanistan. The same qualities that drew him to join the military would be the same qualities that would lead him to play a different role on his return. He was respected, looked up to, seen as a genuinely honest and principled individual; everything those who send our young people in to these predatory wars are not.

I recommend the reader take the time to watch
The Pat Tillman Story.  One cannot help doubt the official version of his death on watching this while at the same time feeling proud and impressed by his mother and father and the struggle they went through to get to the truth.

Most importantly, lets not continue to be fooled and let’s tell the truth about what the military is for. It is an offensive force, not a defensive one. And for so many it’s simply a job; often the only decent one around.