by Michael Roberts
I made a presentation to the Marxism Festival 2014 over the weekend (http://marxismfestival.org.uk/). The presentation was called The nature of the current Long Depression. There were three things that I wanted to argue in that presentation.
First, I argued that Marx’s law of the tendency of the rate
of profit to fall was the underlying cause of the cycle of recurrent
crises (booms and slumps) in modern economies, including the Great
Recession. Suffice it to say that mainstream economics has no convincing
explanation of recurrent crises. As Nobel economics prize winner Eugene
Fama put it: “We don’t know what causes recessions. I’m not a
macroeconomist so I don’t feel bad about that. We’ve never known.
Debates go on to this day about what caused the Great Depression.
Economics is not very good at explaining swings in economic activity….If
I could have predicted the crisis, I would have. I don’t see it. I’d
love to know more what causes business cycles.”
Now Thomas Piketty, author of the best-selling economics book of the
21st century, called Capital in the 21st century (see my posts, http://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2014/04/23/a-world-rate-of-profit-revisited-with-maito-and-piketty/)
has been quick to dismiss Marx’s law as plain wrong in fact. As Piketty
puts it in his book, with the same title as Marx’s 19th century
version: “the rate of return on capital is a central concept in many
economic theories. In particular, Marxist analysis emphasises the
falling rate of profit – a historical prediction that has turned out to
be quite wrong”.
Well, in my presentation, I show the work of Esteban Maito (Maito, Esteban – The historical transience of capital. The downward tren in the rate of profit since XIX century)
on what has happened to the rate of profit in an amalgam of 14
countries since Marx developed his law of profitability in the mid-19th
century, arguing that it was the most important law of all political
economy. Here is my version of Maito’s data.
Marx’s prediction has been confirmed. The global rate of profit has
been in secular decline. But not straight down because there have been
periods of upturn when the counteracting factors to Marx’s law
dominated, if only for a while. Look at the neoliberal period from the
early 1980s to the late 1990s – a period we are all familiar with. The
rate of profit rose but really that rise was just a small interlude in
the long decline in capitalist profitability. This persistent downward
tendency in the rate of profit regularly creates conditions when
capitalists stop investing with some going bankrupt and provoking
financial panics and crashes and then causing a cascade into a slump of
investment, output, employment and incomes.
The second point that I made was that sometimes this regular
cycle of boom and slump is interrupted and a recession or slump turns
into a depression. By a depression I mean that any recovery is weak and
does not re-establish the previous rate of economic growth, investment
or employment. These ‘winter’ phases (see the graph above) only come
around every 50-70 years. And we are now in one.
The schematic graph below shows the difference between a recession and a depression.
A recession can take the form of a v-shape before returning to trend
growth or a w-shape as in a double-dip recession. But a depression is
more a square-root shape as output never gets back to trend growth.
There have been three depressions: one in the late 19th century, the
Great Depression of the 1930s and the current one.
Do depressions come to an end and under what circumstances? That was the third
point of the presentation. Well, clearly the first two did. As Marx
said “there is no permanent crisis”. If sufficient value is destroyed in
a slump or series of slumps (depressions contain more than one
recession), eventually the profitability of the remaining capital is
restored to levels that encourage a new round of accumulation. Then, as
Marx put it, the whole ‘crap’ starts again.
Does it require a world war? Would the Great Depression of the 1930s
have carried on forever if there had been no world war? Well, the 19th
century Long Depression came to an end without any world war. So we can
expect that this current winter will come to an end – in my view – not
through world war. Failing a successful revolution in a major capitalist
economy, capitalism will eventually enter a new ‘spring’ with a
recovery in profitability and new investment growth based on new
technologies already ‘discovered’ but just waiting for development.
Of course, each time, the system finds it more difficult to develop
that new technology as it becomes more and more unproductive in the
capitalist sense. Unless replaced with a mode of production based on
ownership in common and a democratically controlled plan for the world
to meet the needs of people, capitalism will continue to engender
poverty, inequality, recurrent (and ever increasingly destructive)
crises in employment, income and health. And it is fast destroying
nature and through global warming generating ever more extreme weather
and environmental disasters.
My power point presentation is available here Marxism 2014 and my notes are available here The nature of current long depression. The meeting was recorded so there should be a ‘you tube’ thingy soon.
This brings me to my second item: socialists in Slovenia. The United
Left party has apparently won 6% of the votes in Slovenia’s snap general
election to gain six seats in parliament. The United Left is a
coalition of two socialist parties that includes the Initiative for
Democratic Socialism, which is a party formed out of the socialist
students in the Workers and Punks University and the Institute of Labour
Studies in Ljubljana.
As readers of this blog will know, I have been to Slovenia to present
papers at the invitation of this grouping on two occasions, the second
time as part of the launch of the IDS
The entry of the United Left into parliament is a great leap for Slovenia and small step for socialism.
- AFSCME Local 444 negotiations assesment 1997
- Preparing for Revolution: A discussion document
- The Internal lives of Revolutionary Organizations
- Socialist Alternative members: Questions and Answers
- Sanders: Our Alternative
- The Nature of the New European Left
- Catastrophic Climate Change: Caused by Capitalism
- University of California workers and Unions
- An Invitation to Our Readers
- Facts For Working People Weekly Phone Conferences and Discussions