El Golpe: U.S. Labor, the CIA, and the Coup at Ford in Mexico

Readers of this blog may recall the campaign Facts For working People was involved in to pressure Richard Trumka, former AFL-CIO president to make public the AIFLD (American Institute For Free Labor Development) archives. Two former UAW officials Rob McEnzie and Frank Hammer whose brother was assassinated in San Salvador in 1981, were the impetus behind the campaign. McKenzie, as a former president of a Ford local in St Paul MN had built links with workers at a Ford plant in Mexico City who were attacked violently by organized gangs. His investigation in to the forces behind this assault resulted in a book El Golpe, that is reviewed here by Professor Kim Scipes. Facts For Working People is proud to have been a small part of this process and grateful to Rob McKenzie for his efforts to discover the truth behind the attack and strengthening international solidarity and to Kim Scipes for sharing his review with us.  This review was originally published in Covert Action Magazine. Admin

As Workers Win Victories in Mexico, It’s Important to Remember Past Machinations Against Them 

 

Assembly line at Ford plant in Cuautitlán. [Source: fordauthority.com]

 by Kim Scipes

 

As information makes it way north in February 2022, detailing the victory of workers establishing an independent union in GM’s Silao, Mexico plant in the central part of that country—for one source, see Dan DiMaggio and Luis Feliz Leon’s February 4 article at https://labornotes.org/2022/02/landslide-victory-mexican-gm-workers-vote-independent-union–it’s good to remember the struggles of earlier workers who sought the same. 

Rob McKenzie’s (assisted by Patrick Dunne) new book, El Golpe: U.S. Labor, the CIA, and the Coup at Ford in Mexico, does just that.  McKenzie details the collaboration between the AFL-CIO’s regional organization, AIFLD (American Institute for Free Labor Development), the CIA (Central Intelligence Agency), the US State Department, the Mexican government, leaders of the CTM (Mexican labor movement) and Ford Motor Company management against a democratic, rank-and-file, shopfloor-based organization of auto workers at

Ford’s Cuautitlán Assembly Plant near Mexico City in 1990-91.

While the conflict at Cuautitlán is the heart of the book, McKenzie places it in the broader struggle against the AFL-CIO’s foreign policy, a policy this writer—but not McKenzie—has long described as “labor imperialism.”  McKenzie begins by discussing the AFL-CIO’s work in British Guiana in the early 1960s, as well as its role in overthrowing democratically-elected governments in Brazil (1964) and Chile (1973), and their efforts to maintain the established, military-dominated social order in El Salvador in the 1980s.  These precedents are important, in that they add to the previously-established knowledge about these cases, and they show that AIFLD’s work in Mexico was not an aberration but “business as usual.”

When he focuses his attention to Mexico, McKenzie does so from a particular view, that of an American autoworker, an electrician and a UAW (United Auto Workers) union member, and as a former elected president of UAW local 879 at the St. Paul (Minnesota) Ford Assembly Plant.  Additionally, this UAW local had established ties with the Ford workers at Cuautitlán prior to the assault, the “coup,” on these auto workers.  Thus, McKenzie brings a range of experiences and understandings to the situation that one doesn’t usually find in books written by academics.  In fact, it was because of his experiences as an autoworker, and particularly one from this plant, that drove his determination to try to find out what happened in January 1990 in Cuautitlán. 

Buy this book 

To do this, McKenzie starts with discussing the situation during the late 1980s in Mexico and the shift of the auto industry out of the upper US Midwest and into Mexico and Latin America.  It’s all about the search for cheap, compliant labor; inefficient or corrupt unions; unlimited management control; and the resulting higher profits.

He also looks at the emerging development policies of the Mexican government, and ties this in with the then-forthcoming NAFTA, the North American Free Trade Agreement—initiated under US President George H.W. Bush and then signed by Bill Clinton—that would tie Mexico into tighter alliance with the US and Canada.  Basically, Mexico was offering its “cheaper labor” in exchange for capital investment by US and Canadian multinational corporations.  The plan was to get them to invest in Mexico and tax their production, which would enable Mexico to then further develop its economy.

Ford, along with GM and Chrysler, as well as Japanese and Korean auto companies, decided to take advantage of Mexico’s cheap labor, compliant unions, agreeable government, and proximity to the US.

The “problem” was that Mexican autoworkers at Cuautitlán refused to accept the “proposition” chosen for them.  They organized, rid themselves of the corrupt union leadership, and decided to fight to improve their workplace while raising their wages and accompanying standard of living.

It was this project—standing up for themselves and other Mexican workers—that had to be sabotaged.  Working with the corrupt leadership of the CTM (Confederation of Mexican Workers) which was incorporated within the Mexican state by the then-dominant PRI (Institutional Revolutionary Party), and supported by the CIA, the US State Department and with at least the acquiescence of some of the Ford Cuautitlán management, someone sought to break the insurgent union organization.  Approximately 300 gangsters were recruited, armed, hopped up on drugs, and led into the plant, where eight insurgent workers were shot, and one was assassinated at point-blank range, as workers battled the gangsters.

McKenzie, aided by some interviews conducted by a Mexican graduate student on his behalf with former Cuautitlán workers, vividly details events at and inside the plant.  He also reports that other workers inside the plant fought the gangsters, forced them out, and then 2,000 workers began a plant occupation that lasted for another 15 days.

Making this account the more powerful, as suggested above, McKenzie doesn’t just limit his focus on this particular auto plant.  Noting that almost no one was prosecuted or penalized in any way, he begins trying to understand how that could happen:  who could have organized and armed 300 men, plus gotten them Ford ID badges, which enabled them to enter the plant unchallenged?  And who could almost certainly ensure that the criminals would not be prosecuted?  In whose interests would something like this advance?  And then, who would possibly assassinate the leader of the armed men within a year?

 

Tammy Baldwin

Encouraged by friends and colleagues in the UAW, he kept trying to answer these questions.  He tied AIFLD into the CIA, and shows how they worked together; something long known, especially in Latin America, but with considerably more detail provided here than previously established.  He got help from the staff of US Senator Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), who freed some documents from the US State Department, which had been trying to cover up the coup and had refused McKenzie’s previous “Freedom of Information Act” requests.  He badgered Ford for information but, to date, the company has refused to comment on the assault and how the gangsters got Ford ID cards, Ford jackets, and got into the plant.  He sought information from the UAW itself, as well as the AFL-CIO, but no one would respond.  The CIA refused to respond to his requests.

McKenzie then leads the reader on an effort to solve the “who done it?,” detailing the ups and downs he went through to get to the bottom of this crime.  This includes being stone-walled by the AFL-CIO, the UAW, archivists of the Walter Reuther Papers at Wayne State University in Detroit, and at the CIA.  Ultimately, and despite others’ efforts, archivists at the George Meany Memorial Papers at the University of Maryland at College Park were able to help him.  He got additional help from Senator Baldwin’s office.  It is clear that “someone” didn’t want him finding answers to his questions; his perseverance undercut their efforts.

In his conclusion, McKenzie writes,

“In the world of study into CIA covert operations, researchers can never completely prove Agency involvement in matters. Some speculation is required to reach a logical conclusion about events” (195).

 

After working through the material he found and/or gained access to in a logical and systematic manner, he concluded, “The process of elimination leaves the CIA as an institution with the motive and the capability of sponsoring the attack” (200).  I think it is a very well founded conclusion; Columbo would be proud.

McKenzie considers the impact of labor leaders working with the CIA through AIFLD:

Organized labor was launched on a path of decline during the Cold War, resulting in it becoming a marginalized societal force in the twenty-first century. The full part that the AFL-CIO’s collaboration with the CIA contributed to this deterioration, and the responsibility that the Agency’s infiltration and manipulation of labor played in its demise, is still undetermined.  It has been over 30 years since the Cold War ended, and the AFL-CIO has still never publicly addressed the issue of its collaboration with the CIA during that period. It is difficult to imagine a new labor movement emerging without coming to terms with this past (202).

 

Once you read this book, I think most readers will come to a conclusion similar to McKenzie’s.

 

The question remaining—which is largely beyond the scope of this book, but definitely still on the table—is what to do about the AFL-CIO’s foreign policy today?  Working through the misleadingly-named National Endowment for Democracy (NED), the AFL-CIO’s Solidarity Center still currently operates around the world, behind the backs of US union members and even most of their leaders, funded overwhelmingly by the US government (under both political parties), and without any honest reporting of their operations to affiliated unions and their members.  While not as bad as AIFLD and its earlier contemporaries in Africa and Asia, it still is a dagger at the throat of social justice and popular democracy efforts around the world:  when will we union members stop it?

---

 

Kim Scipes, Ph.D., is a Professor of Sociology at Purdue University Northwest in Westville, Indiana.  He is the author of the 2010 book, AFL-CIO’s Secret War against Developing Country Workers:  Solidarity or Sabotage?, and of the 2020 article, “The AFL-CIO’s Foreign Policy Program:  Where Historians Now Stand,” available on-line for free from the peer-reviewed journal Class, Race and Corporate Power (Political Science Department of Florida International University in Miami):  https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/classracecorporatepower/vol8/iss2/5.  He is also a member of the National Writers’ Union, AFL-CIO.  Details on McKenzie’s book:  London:  Pluto Press, 2022  ISBN:  978 0 7453 4562 8 (paper).