by Michael Roberts
There was a batch of economic data out today that confirmed that
the global economic expansion since the end of the Great Recession in
mid-2009 was in trouble. The ‘recovery’ since then has already been the
weakest since the 1930s.
Now data for the last quarter of 2015 from major capitalist economies
showed that economic growth, as measured by real GDP growth, was
slowing. In preliminary figures for the US economy, the most important
and fastest growing of the major economies, in Q4 2015, real GDP rose
only at a 0.7% annual rate, sharply down from the 2% pace recorded from
Q3 2015. That meant the US economy had expanded in real terms (after
inflation is deducted) by 2.4% in 2015, the same rate as in 2014. But
the worrying sign was that in Q4 2015, the yoy rate was only 1.8%,
virtually the same rate as the UK economy achieved in that last quarter.
And the prospects for 2016 are probably worse. Earlier this week,
figures for US durable goods orders, a measure of future investment
purchases by America’s companies, showed a fall of 4.3% in December,
making a 7.5% drop over the year.
Indeed, the real GDP figures released today showed that business
investment contracted at a 1.8% annual pace, the first quarterly fall
for over two years. In 2015, investment rose only 2.9%, the slowest
rate since 2010. And it’s investment that drives a capitalist economy not consumption, as I have argued ad nauseam on this blog.
And earlier this week, we got the figures for the next fastest
growing major capitalist economy, the UK. In the last quarter of 2015,
UK real GDP grew at just a 0.5% rate (even slower than the US) and the
slowest rate for three years. For 2015 as a whole, real GDP rose 2.2%
down from 2.9% in 2014. Moreover, the economy was only larger by 1.9% in
the last quarter – a sign that economic expansion was weakening. Most
significant was that while UK real GDP has moved above its pre-crisis
peak that is only because British population has risen, with the influx
of migrants from mainly eastern Europe. Real GDP per head is virtually
the same as it was in 2o08, eight years ago!
And the UK’s growth is led by an expansion in ‘services’.
Manufacturing has been contracting. The main sector for growth has been
in the financial and business services around the City of London. A
new financial crash would soon put that in jeopardy
In the Eurozone, the situation remains worse than in the US and the
UK. Spain has been recovering and recorded a 0.8% rise in the last
quarter of 2015, led by ‘services’ and property. But the French economy
is staggering along with just a 0.2% rise, thus achieving a growth rate
of just 1.3% in 2015. The forecast at the beginning of 2015 was for
1.5%. The IMF forecasts 1.6% for this year. That must be in doubt. As
for Germany, the forecast for the last quarter is for little or no
And then there is Japan. Remember a few years ago, we were told that
the new prime minister Abe had a plan to get the Japanese economy going
through a mixture of monetary injections (quantitative easing), fiscal
stimulus (government spending) and neo-liberal labour market reforms. Keynesian
economists like Paul Krugman and Noel Smith were very keen on
‘Abenomics’ as confirmation of the efficacy of Keynesian policy, especially as it would include a depreciation of the yen’s value to boost exports and growth.
Well, today the Bank of Japan announced that it was going to
introduce a ‘negative deposit rate’ for banks keeping cash with it. In
effect, it would penalize Japanese banks for keeping excess cash with
it. This is a desperate attempt to kick-start the economy and a major
admission that current ‘Keynesian’ policies had dismally failed. Real GDP is crawling along and real household spending is falling, down 4.4% in December from a year ago while industrial production is contracting 1.4% yoy.
The BoJ acted just a day after one of the key architects of Abenomics. Akira Amari, was forced to resign as economy minister following allegations that he and his aides received bribes from a construction company.
The rest of Asia is slowing down too. We all know about China where growth has slowed to its slowest rate in a decade. But
Taiwan also announced that its economy barely grew in 2015. Elsewhere,
energy producer, Canada is in a ‘technical recession’, two quarters of
contraction in real GDP and as reported before, the large so-called
emerging economies of Brazil, Russia and South Africa are in deep
And another large emerging economy, tied closely to the US, Mexico
also produced real GDP data that showed a slowdown in the last quarter
of 2015 to 0.6% from 0.8% in Q3. Overall, Mexico grew 2.5% in real
terms in 2015, slightly down from a weak 2.6% in 2014.
Is a new global recession impending? A bunch of mainstream and leftist Keynesian economists were asked their opinion by the UK’s Guardian newspaper. As far as I can read it, only one was forthright that a global recession was coming, although this was Albert Edwards who has been forecasting this for six years and
even now when the recession was coming was not specified. The others
hedged and fudged and were unable to get off the picket fence.
My position has been it is the job of economics to make forecasts
just like any other science, even if that is much more difficult with
social sciences where human decision-making is involved. But just like
weather forecasting, your forecasts will be only as good as your
theoretical foundations and empirical research. Based on Marx’s laws of
motion under capitalism, profitability, debt and investment are key
indicators of boom or slump. On those indicators, as I have argued in previous posts, a global recession is coming.
And as I argued at the beginning of this year, the timing of that has got much closer; maybe this year, but probably by the end of 2017 at the latest.
- AFSCME Local 444 negotiations assesment 1997
- The Internal lives of Revolutionary Organizations
- Socialist Alternative members: Questions and Answers
- Sanders: Our Alternative
- An Invitation to Our Readers
- Facts For Working People Weekly Phone Conferences and Discussions
- Help open The AFL-CIO AIFLD Archives