by Michael Roberts
In this tortuous saga between the leaders of the Eurozone and
the new Greek government over repaying its public sector debt and
continuing with a Troika-imposed austerity programme, we must remember
that the cause of all this mess is the failure of capitalism in Europe
Yes, the Syriza government has retreated massively from its original
position to cancel or renegotiate the ‘odious’ debt burden and it has
given way on some (many?) of the immediate measures it wanted to take on
reversing austerity and improving the hugely reduced living standards
of Greek households. But that was inevitable if the government wants to
sustain Greek capitalism inside or outside the Eurozone. Greek capital
is the weakest in the spectrum of European capital, where Germany and
France are strongest. They call the tune.
So the real villain of the piece is Capital in the persona of
Franco-German capital and their supporters in the governments of the
other ‘distressed’ EMU states of Spain, Portugal and Ireland, as well as
There are many commentators, including those on the Keynesian left,
who complain that the Germans are being unreasonable and stupid. Giving
the Greeks some leeway on public spending and reducing the burden of
debt would help restore the Greek economy and keep the European project
going in the face of increased scepticism from the electorate of Europe
and a stagnating and deflating Euro economy. You see, austerity does
not work, so goes the argument (http://mainlymacro.blogspot.co.uk/2015/02/greece-and-educating-economists.html).
But the Germans are not ‘irrational’ from the point of view of
Capital. The Austerians reckon that European capitalism will not
recover unless the capitalist sector is restored to high profitability
and the burden of debt is reduced. That means neoliberal ‘structural’
reforms involving primarily decimating the power of labour through
anti-trade union laws, increased sacking rights, reducing unemployment
benefits and pensions and more privatisations. Alongside this, there
must be cuts in public spending and debt to allow cuts in corporate
taxation to raise profitability. Get labour costs down and boost
profitability – that’s the way out of this depression (https://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2012/04/14/the-austerity-debatehttps://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2012/09/30/can-austerity-work/).
That is a rational strategy for Capital. The Keynesians, on the
other hand, reckon that cutting wages and fiscal austerity just slashes
‘effective demand’, so that more austerity breeds even less growth. In
the depth of depression, this argument has some validity, especially in
Greece. But the essence of recovery on a capitalist basis must be a
return to profitability and raising wages or spending more on welfare
does the opposite (https://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2015/02/08/the-causes-of-recovery-austerity-qe-and-the-spending-multiplier/).
So the German intransigence flows from an ideological belief that
fiscal austerity and wage-cutting programmes are essential. As the
Germans are not committed in any way to proper fiscal union in Europe
(see my post, https://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2015/02/12/red-lines-and-fiscal-union/),
they do not want to make any (or the most minimal) concessions to
Syriza. Moreover, they are backed in this by the venal, corrupt and
harsh neoliberal governments still in office in Spain, Portugal and
Ireland who have imposed Troika programmes on their people and who would
be badly undermined if there are better terms for a leftist government
in Greece. The feeble pro-capitalist social democratic governments of
Italy and France, both trying to impose ‘structural reforms’ on labour,
also go along with this.
Unfortunately, propaganda in Germany and the rise of Eurosceptic
forces have led the German electorate to believe that the Greeks are
lazy, are all on benefits, get huge pensions and are corrupt.
Apparently, 66% of Germans asked do not want the Greeks to get any
concessions. Of course, this characterisation of the Greek working
class is nonsense.
Greeks work more hours in a year than any other country in Europe –
and more than even the Americans or Brits! And surprisingly, it is the
Germans who are the ‘laziest’, if measured by hours worked.
Although Greek economy-wide productivity started from a low base when
the country joined the Eurozone in 1999, growth in labour productivity
since then has been faster than the strong capitalist economies of
Germany or France, up 25% compared to just 10% in Germany.
The reason Germany has been so competitive has not been because the
growth in its productivity of labour was so good, but because wages have
risen the least, just 22% since 1999 compared to nearly double in
Ireland and up two-thirds in Greece (see my post, https://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2013/09/22/german-capitalism-a-success-story/).
So while Greeks saw their living standards improve under the euro
until the crisis came, they did this by working the longest hours and by
being exploited more than any other workforce in Europe. The biggest
gainers from joining the euro were the Greek capitalists. The fruits of
increased economic growth and trade went to them disproportionately.
The wage share in Greek national income fell nearly 4% pts, a fall only
surpassed by Spain and more even than American workers suffered
In my view, Syriza was correct to say that it wanted to stay in the
euro and campaign for removing the debt burden and reversing austerity.
To start from the view that Greece must leave the euro and then look at
‘reversing austerity’ puts the cart before the horse and also runs in
the face of the aspirations of Greeks to be ‘part of Europe’.
But what is wrong
with Syriza’s position (in my view) is to see the issue of debt and
‘fiscal space’ as the main (sole?) issues and have the illusion that the
Eurogroup leaders will see it is in their interest to save European
capitalism from a serious blow if Greece is thrown out of the euro. As
we now know, Greek finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, says he aims to
save capitalism from the stupid policies of neoliberalism, get some time
to recover and then look at socialist measures some way down the road
when capitalism is on a better footing (see my heavily criticised post,
What’s wrong with both the Syriza leadership position and that of the
left within Syriza is that they have put the debt burden and the euro
on the front burner rather than replacing failed Greek capitalism at
home as the top priority. Whether Greece is in or out the euro will not
restore growth and living standards if the capitalist sector continues
to dominate in Greece. Greece’ s public sector debt can never be repaid
and should be written off as odious. But the cost of servicing it has
fallen to low levels already, so writing it off will not alone
kick-start the economy.
The Greek government and its people must seize control of the
commanding heights of the economy. That means public ownership and
democratic control of the banks and the major strategic companies; the
launch of a public investment programme for jobs and growth and an
appeal to solidarity within Europe for the Greek alternative against the
neo-liberal governments in the Eurogroup. That would probably lead to
Greece being ousted from the EU, given the current balance of political
forces. But at least the Greek people and the rest of Europe would see
why the Euro leaders are doing it and also have a clear alternative plan
B to implement (https://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2011/09/11/an-alternative-programme-for-europe/).
The danger now is that Syriza will agree to a compromise with the EU
leaders that ‘saves’ Greek and Euro capitalism at the expense of little
or no improvement in the conditions for the bulk of Greek people. All
that does is postpone the crunch between reversing austerity and the
interests of Capital, without a Plan B in the interests of Labour.
- AFSCME Local 444 negotiations assesment 1997
- Preparing for Revolution: A discussion document
- The Internal lives of Revolutionary Organizations
- Socialist Alternative members: Questions and Answers
- Sanders: Our Alternative
- The Nature of the New European Left
- Catastrophic Climate Change: Caused by Capitalism
- University of California workers and Unions
- An Invitation to Our Readers
- Facts For Working People Weekly Phone Conferences and Discussions